Beberapa Gambar Sekitar Gerakerja Di Kawasan Jerai


Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Temple Demolition in Ampang

I want to say something about the demolition of the Sri Maha Kaliamman temple in Kampung Tasek Ampang and the controversy that surrounds it.

I was so shocked and sad when I first learned about it. A friend of mine sent me a text message informing me of it. I actually did not believe it, and thought how stupid can the government be by actually allowing such incidents to happen again. This was actually one of the main issues or factors that actually worked totally against the BN, especially in Selangor when the temple in Shah Alam was demolished then.

I called some of my friends up who confirmed the incident. They were obviously mad about the whole issue and were disappointed that MPAJ and the Selangor State Government were responsible for the demolition. What happened to the promises by the PKR about protecting and upholding the rights of the Hindus (Makkal Sakhti) and of other faiths?

But what I would like to do here is take this opportunity to actually tell all my friends, especially Hindu friends how sad and sorry I am that this had happened again. I feel embarrassed, angry and sad that the people in this beautiful country of ours have to go through this problem once again. Even sadder when we, as a nation, are preparing to celebrate Hari Raya AidilFitri together.

We must respect all faiths that are being practiced throughout the world and in this country. Article 11 of our Constitution says and I quote “ Artikel 11 Perlembagaan Malaysia menyatakan bahawa Islam merupakan Agama rasmi Persekutuan. Sungguh pun begitu setiap orang berhak mempraktikkan agamanya sendiri.” – (googled it under Perlembagaan Malaysia).

Everyone has the right to practise whatever his belief and religion. That is enshrined in the Constitution. No person or persons, organisations or authority should have the right to demolish any places of worship for any religion without exhausting all avenues first. These avenues must also be spelled out clearly, so that everyone knows what needs to be done first before such demolition can actually take place.

I am sad when Dr Xavier, the Selangor State EXCO in charge alleged that the demolition was done because the temple (or shrine as he put it) was on State Forest Reserve land. He might be right, but he should have discussed it first and seek proper recourse and arrive to an amicable solution. We must understand the sensitivities and it is only right if there really is a need to demolish, it must be done amicably, after much discussion and consultation, with dignity and honour. After all, I trust that we Malaysians are a reasonable lot and open to rational discussions and views.

And as the EXCO in charge, it is unbecoming of him to answer that MPAJ did not inform him first. If that be the case, then he is no better than the infamous Dato Seri Syed Hamid Albar, who could not exert control over his portfolio. Dr Xavier must not answer like a bureaucrat. He must not hide behind rules. Politicians are entrusted by the Rakyat to make policies, and those policies which are not good for the country and rakyat – well that is why MPs, State Assemblymen and so on are called policy makers. To make or change policies for the good of the country and her Rakyat.

If there is a need for the proposed Race Relations Act - this is it. I am actually not totally in favour of the Race Relations Act as yet, because I do not need an Act to tell me how to treat my friends of various races and beliefs. But this might just swing it for me, if this proposed act will address problems, controversies and issues such as these for all faiths and religion.

I pray to god that such insensitive acts will not happen again in this great country of ours.


Zool said...


first of all salam to you and thank you for introducing me to your blog. Its refreshing to know that within the UMNO circles we have peole concerned about issues and not only politics!

Quoting from second last para of your write-up;

"...if this proposed act will address problems, controversies and issues such as these for all faiths and religion."

The current Govt has failed to address many problems plaguing the country. My question is whether this new Act will be administered properly and/or will benefit the rakyat. We recently sw how the ISA was abused and I as other rakyat are worried that this will be the same with the RRA. Professor Dr Shamsul Amri Baharuddin of UKM believes that this is a knee-jerk reaction to the Datuk Ahmad Ismail issue. If the Govt had addressed this DAI issue fairly and properly, then we would not need this RRA.

Having said that, if the RRA is to ensure that people are not discriminated against for jobs or education then that would be good. But I believe that more thought must be put into this Act. We do not want this to be a mini-ISA for future (ab)use!

Wishing you and your family a Blessed Eid-Mubarak. Salam.

Faizal Zakaria's Blog said...

Selamat menyambut hari lebaran semuanya :-)
Saya doakan semuanya berbahagia dan selamat pulang ke destinasi ;-)

Amalan Rasuah Dan Pemuda UMNO Perlu Dibersihkan ;-)